Present Perfect or Past Simple
News now, details then: I've found a flat! I found it on Monday.
Ask two questions. Is the time named or asked about (yesterday, ago, when)? Then the past simple. If not, is it linked to now (experience, news, a period still going on)? Then the present perfect; if not, the past simple.
Do you name or ask when it happened? (yesterday, ago, in 2020, when?)
| Past simple | Present perfect |
|---|---|
| yesterday, last week, two days ago | ever, never, so far |
| in 2020, on Monday, when I was ten | just, already, yet |
| When…? What time…? | for / since up to now, How long…? |
incorrect: I have bought this coat two weeks ago.
correct: I bought this coat two weeks ago.
Ago names a finished moment, so the past simple. The present perfect does not go with ago, yesterday or last.
The news: present perfect
I've found a new flat!
First you give the news. No time yet: what matters is the result now.
The details: past simple
I found it on Monday. It cost less than I expected.
Then the details: when, where, how. Now the moment is fixed, so switch to the past simple.
News, then details
- 01
I've passed my driving test! — Well done! When did you take it?
The news is present perfect; the question about when is past simple.
- 02
There's been an accident. A car hit a tree at about eight.
'There's been' gives the news; the details move into the past simple.
- 03
Our team has won the cup! They scored in the last minute.
'In the last minute' fixes the moment, so 'scored'.
How long…? — up to now
How long have you lived here? — For five years.
A period from the past up to now: present perfect, answer with for or since.
When…? — a moment
When did you move here? — In 2020.
A point in the past: past simple, answer with in, on or ago.
When did you start your new job?
Коли ви почали працювати на новій роботі?
incorrect: When have you arrived?
correct: When did you arrive?
When asks about a finished moment, so the past simple. The present perfect does not name or ask when.